Took the PSAT, got a NMS index of 218 (well above what the expected cutoff for the US is, but likely a few points too low for my home state cutoff for the official scholarship.
Do you mean here on CV or on your application itself? NMS Commended usually goes on the Awards/Honors section of the Common App, and it's relatively prestigious.
Congrats on doing so well on the PSAT, you must've worked hard! I agree that you should err on the side of caution when choosing between what tier to rank it as. If you think it's a C or D tier, go D.
To keep this community safe and supportive:
Both. I am wondering about Collegevine because it seems to be between a C and D tier depending on which metric is being used.